The most helpful of all the methods of fostering the Patrol spirit is by
having a continuous competition between the various Patrols. By
"continuous" is meant that as soon as one competition is over the next
one has begun. In most Troops it will be found best to arrange things in the
nature of a six-monthly or even three-monthly contest rather than as a
competition of a year's duration. If the period is too long, it is found that
the Patrols which get far behind in their marks tend to lose interest and become
slack. On the other hand, where the competition takes place twice or four times
a year, the interest and excitement is always kept alive, and a Patrol which
gets far behind will not have to wait many weeks before making a fresh start in
a new struggle for supremacy.
The important question to be considered is what the competition is to be for.
If a Scoutmaster decides this question by himself he will find that the Patrol
Competition falls flat. It has already been pointed out that a Scoutmaster who
is thinking what he wants and not what his boys want can hardly complain if he
fails to find much scouting enthusiasm in his Troop. The question as to what the
subjects for competition are to be is, therefore, one for the Court of Honor.
In fact, where there is a Patrol Competition, a weekly meeting of the Court of Honor
is almost indispensable.
The general principle of the Patrol Competition is that there should be
points for every subject in which all the Patrols have an equal opportunity of
competing, and points should be awarded in such a way that the youngest Patrol,
or smallest physically, has as good a chance of winning as the oldest and
biggest. It is certain that the Court of Honor will unanimously decide in favor of points for attendance. A good method is to give a maximum of 100
points for six months, and, perhaps, five points off for the non-attendance of
any boy at a compulsory parade. If the Chief's Patrol Report Form be used, the
competition can be fixed upon the percentage system. (The percentage of
attendances is given on the back of the form for the purpose of comparing the
merits of the respective Patrols.)
It has already been mentioned in a previous chapter how either the
Scoutmaster or the Patrol Leader makes a note of all absences at a parade. The
names of those absent in each Patrol are read out at the Court of Honor, and
the Leader is asked whether he can give any reason for the absence of Scout
Brown from his Patrol. If he has no adequate reason to give, five points will be
taken off. If he gives a reason, it is for the Court of Honor to decide whether
it is adequate, In any case an absent Scout should inform his Patrol Leader or
Second beforehand that he cannot attend, and on the parade night the Leader will
then be able to account for all his Patrol to the Scoutmaster. If a boy is found
to have had a proper reason for being absent, but to have omitted to inform his
Leader beforehand, the Court may decide that he is to lose two or three points
instead of five.
In towns it will be found that much of the time of the Court of Honor is
saved by making some general rules with regard to absence from a parade. For
instance, in most London Troops it would be laid down that attendance at Evening Classes counts as a parade, provided
that the Scout notifies the Court of Honor in advance.
The Court will probably also decide that there should be points for badges
earned during the six months. They might give five points for each badge earned.
Perhaps more for a First Class or King's Scout badge, and perhaps two points for
a Tenderfoot. These are only suggestions, but it is often found that by giving a
special mark for a certain badge the Court of Honor may encourage the Troop to
work hardest for the badges which are the most important to get. Points may
further be allotted for competitions in Knot-tying, Signaling, First Aid,
Firelighting, Relay Racing, and any other badge work. A good method of running a
Knot-tying competition is by presenting each boy with a piece of cord, by
telling him to hold it behind his back, and then by giving the order that he
should tie a bowline. At the end of a minute "time" is called. The
Patrol that has tied seven Bowlines will have seven points and the Patrol that
has tied two Bowlines will have only two. A Fire-lighting competition may he
conducted by giving each Patrol a box of matches and a billy, and by awarding
points for the Patrol which first produces a cup of boiling water. An examiner
once decided upon an omelet as the final test instead of boiling water, but he
found himself confronted by the unanswerable riddle as to "What is an omelet?" He found that the only answer was, "Something that cannot
be mistaken either for a pancake or for scrambled eggs.
Some member of the Court of Honor is certain to suggest points for
smartness, but the marks for smartness should certainly be fairly small, for it
is rather an invidious and difficult thing for either the Scoutmaster or anybody
else to decide fairly which is the smartest Patrol. Smartness in camp is easier
to judge upon, and one may certainly have a competition for the best kept tent.
It should be borne in mind, however, that a smart Patrol does not so much imply
one that has got military polish but rather a Patrol that is always workmanlike
and alert. A good Patrol for instance, carries out orders at the double.
In a Troop of fairly well-educated boys, it is an admirable thing to have a
six-monthly examination on "Scouting for Boys." Each Patrol might
select two of its members to compete. The paper would, perhaps, be set by the
District Commissioner or District Scoutmaster. It might also be a good thing to
have a competition for the best Essay on Scout Law, or for the best Diary, one
Essay or Diary to be sent in from each Patrol.
One Troop has a competition for the best record of Patrol good turns. It
might be thought at first that this would tend to make the boys priggish, but as
a matter of fact it has been found to have just the opposite effect. At any rate
it does a great deal to remind the boys to do their kind actions every day.
There is no reason at all why the subjects for competition should always
remain the same. The Patrol Competition should be elastic, and its object should
be to encourage the Patrols in their scouting work and to keep alive their
keenness and enthusiasm. Boys like competing against one another, and one can
hardly have too many subjects for competition. Some of the best Troops find that
the winning Patrol usually gets anything from 500 to 1,000 points by the end of
the six months.
It will now be asked what is to be the reward for the winning Patrol. Some
Scoutmasters arrange that the Scouts of the best Patrol wear special medals or
decorations. This is contrary to the spirit of the Headquarters rules, and
should, as far as possible, be avoided. There are plenty of official decorations
for boys who are ready to work for them, and a multiplicity of unofficial badges
is to be discouraged. When the boys are free to decorate the walls of their own
headquarters it is an admirable thing to have an Honors Board. The name of the
winning Patrol for every six months should be put upon this board, and perhaps
the name of the Patrol Leader in brackets underneath. In some cases it may be a
good thing to have a Patrol Cup or Patrol Shield. Excellent shields are sold by
Headquarters for this purpose. The winning Patrol Leader might be entitled to
have this shield at his home for a fortnight, and other members of his Patrol for a
week, and for the remaining weeks it would be kept at the Troop Headquarters.
Another thoroughly practicable way of rewarding a Patrol is by allowing it the
privilege of carrying the Troop colors until another Patrol defeats it. The
Chief is also having a scheme of "totems" made out for Patrol
championships-as an incentive to Patrol efficiency.
If a Patrol Leader is not keen that his Patrol should win the competition,
there is something The Scouting Spirit of one of them wants wrong either with
him or with his Scoutmaster. doctoring.
(N.B.-It will have been noticed in the above chapter that the word
"points" has been used rather than the word "marks." To some
boys the term "marks" is unpleasing as being rather too reminiscent of
school.)
