[ Home ] [ Books ] [ Search Inquiry ] [ Contents ]
Lightweight
[ Home ] [ Up ]

by Bob Geier

Whatever we do, it should be aimed at learning on the part of the boys, not on efficiency. It's important to understand that in our case, it was the boys who made all the decisions to change from the "old way" to the "lightweight way" over the years. They decided to dump chuck boxes, they decided to abandon big dining flies (well, actually, they just stopped using 'em), they chose to get rid of the propane gear. I submit that if it's not possible within a troop for the boys to experiment and to change he way the troop works, then we aren't really doing youth leadership, we're just faking it.

I don't think using gear that's efficient and flexible has much downside in terms of our goals. Each boy our way ends up doing more cooking of different meals, but for fewer people. They do less cleaning overall, but they do some cleaning every meal. I see a lot more baking with our setup than I ever saw with propane, but our guys aren't very good fire-builders.

The biggest issue is opportunity cost. Can you learn teamwork lugging gear around? Sure, I guess. The real question is "Can you learn teamwork better if you used that time for something else?" like rigging a low-ropes course together, or navigating/backpacking up a ridge with hikers of different skill and endurance. Lightweight gear has allowed our 11-year-olds to backpack on skis 2 miles into a snow camp... lots of teamwork needed, lots of leadership demanded.... the patrol method in spades.

We rarely bring cans, and only when "plop" camping. We sometimes bring coolers (one SMALL one per patrol) when "plop" camping; we have them anyways. We also have some small plastic cooler-like boxes for foodstuffs in areas where there is a known critter problem.

Remember we live in the north. Got all the refrigeration we need for half of the year anyways! Refrigeration is only needed for "live" meats/proteins in any event.

Our guys tend to design and run their own high adventure stuff. Last time we were at Philmont was '91 or '92, and we ran with the small cook groups. Eight is way too big; the Philmont packaging back then was for four. If it's changed, that's too bad.

Why the grouping of 4 per stove? The biggest reason is that it is more consistent with Leave No Trace, particularly in undeveloped sites. Eight people create a lot of impact on one spot over a weekend.

Second reason is speed and efficiency. Two groups working in parallel get meals done faster, and you double the number of guys who get experience cooking. Even if they're cooking as a patrol, different guys are doing different parts of the meal (teamwork...). Pot size stays manageable (3-liter), bake pan makes a perfect "generous" amount in one round, etc. Particularly in the winter, trying to cook larger amounts gets exponentially harder as the stove is working uphill against the elements. (That's another reason for the lightweight gear; propane is really frustrating in the deep cold).

If you're thinking about experimenting, I'd encourage it! I'd suggest taking your PLC or Venture Patrol and trying it with just them for a bit, then let them make changes as they see fit. It helps you to build a cadre of boys with experience to ease into the transition for the younger guys.

See Also:

Lightweight Troop Equipment

Search  Inquiry Net

[ Back ] [ Home ] [ Up ] [ Next ]

Additional Books

Site Contents
[Warning: Large File]

Additional Information:

Peer- Level Topic Links:
[ 2nd & 1st Class Cooknig ] [ Contests ] [ Dutch Oven Stack ] [ Lightweight ] [ Hygiene ] [ Off-the-Shelf ] [ Camp ] [ Recipes ] [ Primitive ] [ Utensils ]

Parent- Level Topic Links:
[ Archery ] [ Axe, Boy Scout ] [ Axe, Saw, Forestry ] [ Axe, Saw,  Knife ] [ Axe Use: Beard ] [ Axe Use: Seton ] [ Axe Use: Traditional ] [ Axe Throwing ] [ Beds, Woodcraft ] [ Bedding Materials ] [ Bicycle Maintenance ] [ Birch-Bark Torch ] [ Birds ] [ Bird Houses ] [ Blocks Tackles Purchase ] [ Blood Red Cross ] [ Broom: Camp or Witch's ] [ Buttons ] [ Campcraft ] [ Camp Hygiene ] [ Camp Planning ] [ Campfire Programs ] [ Chainsaws ] [ City-Craft ] [ Compass Bear Song ] [ Compass, Home-Made ] [ Cooking ] [ Cotton Kills Bear Song ] [ Deduction in Tracking ] [ Deduction & Detective ] [ Drum ] [ Dyes ] [ Edible Plants ] [ Equipment, Leader ] [ Equipment, Personal ] [ Equipment Maintenance ] [ Equipment, Lightweight ] [ Equipment, Scouting Out ] [ Estimation ] [ Field Signals ] [ Fire Building ] [ Fire Laying ] [ Fire Lighting ] [ Fire Starters ] [ Fire: Rubbing-Stick ] [ Fire Types, Wood Types ] [ Fire Council Ring ] [ Fires: Woodcraft ] [ First Aid ] [ First Class Journey ] [ Flint & Steel ] [ Flowers ] [ Forest ] [ Gesture Signals ] [ Ground to Air Signals ] [ Handicraft Stunts ] [ High Adventure ] [ Hiking ] [ Hike Planning ] [ Indian Sundial Clock ] [ Insect Collecting ] [ Insect Preserve ] [ Indian Well ] [ Knife & Hatchet ] [ Knots, Bends, Hitches ] [ Knots: Diamond Hitch ] [ Knots: Lashings ] [ Knots: Rope Work ] [ Knots: Seton ] [ Knots: Traditional ] [ Knots & Whipping ] [ Lashings ] [ Lashing Practice Box ] [ Lace or Thong ] [ Learn by Doing ] [ Leave No Trace ] [ Lights ] [ Local Knowledge ] [ Log Ladders, Notched ] [ Log-Rolling ] [ Logs: Cut Notch ] [ Logs Split with Axe ] [ Loom and Grass Mats ] [ Lost in the Woods ] [ Manners ] [ Maps ] [ Map & Compass ] [ Maps: Without Compass ] [ Measurement ] [ Measurement Estimation ] [ Menu Worksheet ] [ Menu (Adult IOLS) ] [ Mosquitoes ] [ Mushrooms ] [ Night Tracking ] [ Observation ] [ Old Trails ] [ Paints ] [ Pioneering, Basic ] [ Pioneering Models ] [ Plaster Casts ] [ Preparations ] [ Proverbs ] [ Rake ] [ Rope Care ] [ Rope Making ] [ Rope Spinning ] [ Scout Reports ] [ Signal & Sign ] [ Sign Language ] [ Silent Scout Signals ] [ Smoke Prints ] [ Snakes ] [ Spanish Windlass ] [ Spoons ] [ Staff/Stave Making ] [ Stalking Skills ] [ Stalking & Observation ] [ Stars ] [ Stools ] [ Story Telling ] [ Stoves & Lanterns ] [ Summoning Help ] [ Sun Dial: Scientific ] [ Survival Kit ] [ Tarp Poles ] [ Teepee (4 Pole) ] [ Tent Care ] [ Tent Pitching ] [ Tom-Tom ] [ Tomahawk Throwing ] [ Tomahawk Targets ] [ Totem Making ] [ Totem Animals ] [ Totem Poles ] [ Training in Tracking ] [ Tracks, Ground, Weather ] [ Tracking & Trailing ] [ Trail Following ] [ Trail Signs & Blazes ] [ Trail Signs of Direction ] [ Trail Signs: Traditional ] [ Trail Signs for Help ] [ Trees of the NE ] [ Wall Hangings ] [ Watch Compass ] [ Weather Wisdom ] [ Wild Things ] [ Troop 625 ]

The Inquiry Net Main Topic Links:
[ Traditional Scouting ] [ Adult Association ] [ Advancement ] [ Ideals ] [ Leadership ] [ Outdoors ] [ Patrol Method ] [ Personal Growth ] [ Uniforms ]

External Sponsor Links:

Search Amazon.Com:

Dead Bugs, Blow Guns, Sharp Knives, & Snakes:
What More Could A Boy Want?

Click on Underlined Green text to follow a hyperlink.  Let me know if you find a broken link, especially those that reference a hard drive :-/

Click on Small Pictures to Enlarge Them.  
If this enlarged picture won't print on a single page, search your software for a printing option like "Best Fit."  This is the default setting in most browsers.  
If the pictures are missing, send me the URL, and I'll scan them for you.  

To Email me, replace "(at)" below with "@"
Rick(at)Kudu.Net
If you have questions, you must send me the URL!
The URL tells me what page you're talking about.  This URL is sometimes called the "Address" and it is usually found in a little box near the top of your screen.  Most URLs start with the letters "http://"
Did I mention that you must send me the URL?

©2003, The Inquiry Net, www.inquiry.net: In addition to any Copyright still held by the original authors, the Scans, Optical Character Recognition, extensive Editing,  and HTML Coding on this Website are the property of the Webmaster, Rick Seymour.   My work may be used freely by individuals for non-commercial, non-web-based activities, such as Scouting, research, teaching, and personal use so long as this copyright statement is included in the text. 

The purpose of this Website is to provide access  to hard to find, out-of-print documents.  Much of the content has been edited to be of practical use in today's world and is not intended as historical preservation.   I will be happy to provide scans of specific short passages in the original documents for people involved in academic research.  

The Kudu Net is a backup "mirror" of The Inquiry Net.  When linking to this Website, note that pages that end in "inquiry.net" are updated far more often than the corresponding "kudu.net" versions.

Old School Scouting:
What to Do, and How to Do It!

Since August 24, 2002
+550,762

Last modified: April 03, 2008.